Designing Trust in Low-Trust Markets: Lessons from South Africa's R2.4bn Digital Fraud Problem
South Africa's banks weren't hacked — their customers were persuaded. Here's what SABRIC's latest figures mean for anyone designing high-stakes digital journeys.
The numbers
SABRIC's 2025 Annual Crime Statistics report shows reported digital banking crime claims reached R2.4 billion in 2025 — up 29.2% on 2024 and more than double 2023's R1.09 billion. Incidents rose to 110,074, and the average loss per incident climbed to R21,865.
Banking apps accounted for roughly 89% of digital banking crime cases and 70.5% of claim value. Card fraud added another R1.7 billion, up 18%. Meanwhile, bank robberies fell to two incidents for the entire year. Crime has moved from the vault to the interface.
The app wasn't compromised — the person was
SABRIC is explicit: the prominence of banking apps does not mean the apps were breached. Fraud typically begins outside the platform — a call impersonating the bank or police, urgency, a 'safe account' — and the app is then used, legitimately, to add a beneficiary and approve the payment while the criminal stays on the line.
SABRIC's CEO, Andre Wentzel, put the mechanism plainly to News24: criminals exploit trust, urgency, fear and confusion. Experts estimate reported cases may represent only around 20% of the total.
What this means for UX
If the attack is psychological, part of the defence must be experiential. Security that only lives in back-end rules misses the moment of manipulation — which happens on screen, in the user's hand.
- Design for the coached user. Assume someone may be on the phone telling the user what to tap.
- Add proportional friction at high-risk moments: new beneficiaries, first-time large payments, limit increases.
- Use plain, specific warnings ('The bank will never ask you to move money to a safe account') instead of generic alerts users ignore.
- Make cooling-off and cancellation windows visible and easy.
- Measure trust outcomes — reversed payments, support contacts, abandonment at warnings — alongside conversion.
Trust is a design material
In high-risk, low-trust markets, users have learned to be sceptical — and fraudsters have learned to exploit that same anxiety. The products that win are the ones that make legitimate actions feel safe and suspicious actions feel wrong. That is the brief for our opening 2027 webinar.
Key takeaways
- R2.4bn in digital banking claims in 2025, ~89% of cases via banking apps.
- Social engineering, not system breaches, drives most losses.
- Well-placed, specific friction is a trust feature, not a conversion bug.
Sources
- Annual Crime Statistics 2025 — SABRIC
- SABRIC releases the 2025 Annual Banking Crime Statistics Report — The Banking Association South Africa
- The human compromise: Inside South Africa's R2.4bn digital fraud epidemic — News24
- Bank robberies, ATM bombings collapse as criminals go digital — TechCentral
